Cari and Ellen had formulated a plan. They decided that if they could get Joani to go away with her parents and tell her parents that Cari was going to stay with Ellen then Cari could call Todd on the phone and pretend that she was Joani.
She would ask him to come over; that she had changed her mind about going away at the last minute. Then she would wait for him in Joani's room with the lights out. That's where the plan stopped, but they were certain that Todd would take over from there.
Cari had pretended to be Joani on the phone several times and knew that she could do it. Ellen suggested that she wear Joani's perfume so that he wouldn't know right away. They also thought that she should be naked in the bed just so there could be no doubts as to what was expected of him.
They finally decided that Ellen shouldn't watch since it was Cari's first time. But, of course, Cari would tell her the exact details, thrilling step by thrilling step. Cari said that she would show her exactly what Todd had done and they would make each other come that way if they could.
They put their money together to buy the same kind of perfume that Joani had just in case she took it all with her.
Finally the night came, Cari's parents and Joani left for the plane. Gail said that she would lock up and go to Ellen's just as soon as she finished her homework.
Then they were finally gone. Cari ran to the phone to call Ellen and tell her they had left.
She waited for an hour and phoned the airport to make sure that the plane had left for certain. She dialed Todd's number and hung up before it rang. She took a deep breath and pushed back her long golden hair. She was shaking inside and she felt the blood rising in her pussy. She dialed again, and when Todd's mother answered, she almost forgot to be Joani.
Too quickly Todd was on the phone.
"Joani, I thought you would be gone by now."
"Well, no. I decided that I would rather stay here with you. Cari is going to spend the night with Ellen and well be alone in the house." Cari could hardly hear Todd's answer, the blood was beating so hard in her ears.
"That's great, Joani, but I told my parents that I would go out to dinner with them."
Cari thought for a minute that he was going to refuse. "But I'll be over about nine, okay?"
"Oh, well, that's all right. I have a few things that I should do anyway." She didn't want to sound too anxious.
After she hung up, the called Ellen again, but she hung up after the first ring. Somehow she wasn't ready to share this. She went into the kitchen to fix her dinner. She didn't feel like eating. Her stomach felt strange. She had a glass of milk and went upstairs and took a long hot bubble bath in Joani's bathroom. She used her best bath oil, too, and smiled to herself. She began to feel a little more relaxed.
She dried herself in front of the full-length mirror. She looked at her titties which stood out firmly in front of her. They were larger than Joani's even. She looked at her tanned body. She was tan all over because she and Ellen had sunbathed at the old school house in the country where no one could see.
She hoped that Todd liked her pussy as well as Joani's. Hers was covered with brown curly hair and not red or blonde. She spread her legs apart and looked at her swollen cunt. Soon it would be used for what it was made. Her heart jumped a little at the thought.
She walked into Joani's bedroom and looked at the clock. It was only eight o'clock. She went into her own room to get the perfume. She found it thrilling to be walking through the house with no clothes on.
She spread the perfume slowly over her breasts and down her stomach into the hairs of her twat. She added some to the cheeks of her ass. She was thinking that she never knew where Todd's nose might wander.
She decided that maybe Todd would like a glass of wine after. She had read about that in one of her father's books. She ran downstairs and took a bottle of red wine from the wine cupboard and two glasses.
Upstairs, she arranged then, on the table beside the bed. It was now almost nine o'clock. She turned off the lights and got into bed. She could almost hear her heart thumping.
Then she heard the front door close down stairs.
Then she heard Todd taking steps two at a time.
"Joani? Are you asleep? Why's the light off?" Todd was beside the bed. What now?
"Oh, I might have drifted off while I was waiting." Cari whispered. "Come here, I want you." She pulled Todd down to her.
"Wow, you smell good."
He felt her naked tits. She pulled his head down. Their mouths met and she put her tongue inside of his. He responded and a thrill went through her.
She could feel the juices begin to flow in her cunt Todd tried to pull back. She held him harder. She knew that she couldn't talk as Joani anymore. She really wanted Todd and no pretending.
Todd knew that it wasn't Joani as soon as Cari put her tongue in his mouth. Joani didn't kiss that well even now. He felt that he should stop, but his cock was so big that it was trying to break out of his pants. What a hot little piece this kid was. He had been right Cari knew what she was doing. Should he just go along with the pretense? Why not?
"God, Joani, you really are ready tonight."
He moved his mouth down to her neck and rubbed one of her nipples.
Cari sighed. His mouth tasted the other rosy tip and sucked it softly. Cari felt as if she was going to come. She didn't move. She was afraid that he might stop. He pushed both of her tits together and sucked first one and then, the other.
Cari said, without thinking, "Oh, that's so good."
Todd took one of her hardened nipples and licked it as he put his other hand on her hairy cunt. He felt the creamy hairs and swollen lips. He rubbed some of the cream on her clit, and she moaned.
Cari had waited for this moment her whole life, and Todd knew it. He knew then that he was the first and he wanted it to be very special. More than he had ever cared before. Slowly he felt between those wet lips again. There didn't seem to be an opening. He knew that it wouldn't be that way long. Rut he also knew that it was time to end the charade.
"Cari, I want this to be perfect for you, so let's not pretend any more, okay?"
"All right, Todd."
He kissed her stomach and belly button. Cari arched her back as his lips came close to her swollen clitoris. God, was she ready, Todd thought as his lapping tongue ate up her cunt juices.
Cari felt that she was going to come right away, but Todd stopped just in tim. He took off his shirt and pants and crawled on top of her. Cari could see the outline of his stiff prick as he mounted her.
His cock felt so hard. He held his prick and slowly pushed and pushed a little harder into that waiting pussy until finally he entered.
"That didn't hurt you, did it, Cari?"
Cari could hardly talk. It didn't hurt, and it felt better than she could have imagined or read. His cock was as far as it would go into that slit, and she was moving up and down in with it.
He made it last, but he didn't know whether she would have an orgasm the first time. Just as he was about to pull it out to try a few more things, she begged him, "Don't stop, Todd, I'm coming!"
He let himself go and came with her-her tight snatch pulling and throbbing until his cock let loose all of the squirting juice he had held back for several days.
"Well, now what do you think of yourself, little sister? What would Joani say if she could see us now? You're something. I could take you across my knee and spank you."
"Hey, that sounds like fun," Cari smiled. "Was I all right?"
"Were you all right? That's something I should ask. Yes, you were all right. It took me four dates to talk and trick Joani into letting me touch her and then it took several times for her to come. You really are something, you know, Cari." He turned to her and kissed her tenderly and she teasingly stuck her tongue in his mouth.
"Look you, you'll start things all over again."
"Well, why not? I like it."
"Very well, little darling, whatever you say. But you'll have to give me a few minutes to get ready again."
"That's all right. We've got the whole night. Remember there's no one at home but us."
"Can we turn on the lights now? I'd like to see those tits of yours. And that wiggly little ass you flash by the practice field."
He reached over and turned on the light beside the bed. He saw the bottle of wine and two glasses.
"Boy, you really were prepared. I'm flattered. What made you do this? I mean there are plenty of other guys around."
"I'll tell you someday but not-now. I want it to just be you and me."
She sat up, and Todd saw those delicious jugs.
He reached for one.
Cari reached down and took his limp prick in her hand. She really wanted to look at it more closely, but Todd's head was in her way as he sucked her tit. She didn't want that to stop. She could feel his prick getting hard as she rubbed her hand across the top. It stood straight up in her hand. She was amazed that it felt like velvet across the top.
"Can you fuck me again, Todd?"
He left her tits and lay on her silk-skinned body. He noticed that she was tanned all over. What a girl! She seemed made for sex. He plunged his cock in her tight hot hole. It was slippery and sucked all of the way in.
Cari's body moved with his immediately and they fucked together as if they had been fucking for years. It was beautiful and it lasted and lasted until their bodies vibrated together. It had been as perfect a fuck as Todd had ever had. He couldn't believe his luck.
After they lay there for a few minutes, Todd asked if he were too heavy for her. She whispered no, but she had never felt so deliciously drowsy in her life. Todd said that he could use that drink now. He pulled his limp prick out with a sucking sound. Cari moaned as if he had ripped part of her pussy. He kissed her softly on her belly as he got up.
He opened the bottle of wine and poured them both a glass. She took a few sips of hers and then curled up beside him where he sat on the bed. She fondled his prick as she lay there more asleep than awake.
Todd thought he had better let her sleep now. He didn't want to tire her too much on her first time. He wanted her to remember how great it was and that it was he who had made it great.
"Actually," he whispered, "it was you that made it great." He covered her with Joani's afghan. She was asleep almost immediately.
"Little sister," he whispered, "you're the greatest lay I have had so far. I hope we do it again soon."
She smiled in her sleep as he left.
Cari woke to the ringing phone. At first she didn't know where she was and then, as she realized, a thrill ran through her body. It had happened. She had been fucked by Todd.
"Oh, damn that phone."
It was ringing in her room. She ran naked into her room. As she picked up the phone, the voice on the other end said, "Are you alone?"
It was Ellen and when Cari said that she was alone Ellen answered, "I'll be right over."
Cari hung up the phone and caught a glimpse of herself in the mirror. She didn't look any different, but she sure felt different. She rubbed her tits and pushed them together as Todd had done.
"Wow, it was great."
Now she was glad that Ellen would be there so that she could tell her every detail. It had been fun fooling around with Ellen, and it felt good to masturbate, but fucking with Todd was fantastic.
Before she could run the water in the bathtub, Ellen was ringing the doorbell. She must have run all the way.
Ellen sat beside Cari as she told her of every thrilling moment. When she had finished, Cari wished that she could do it all over again with Todd.
Ellen wished that Todd or someone would fuck her. She didn't want to be a virgin all of her life either.
Cari and Ellen decided to go out for breakfast. They thought that they deserved a treat for their excellent plan.
They went to their favorite pancake house. As they ate, they evaluated the possibilities of each man that came in.
Ellen would say something like, "His shoulders look nice and his arms are strong, but what do you think he has in his prick?"
Cari would answer, "You can't tell by the size. I hear it's what you do with what you've got."
They giggled and ate on. They both felt very grown up. They both felt as if they knew it all now.
Todd's best friend Jim came into the restaurant and said hello to them. He asked Cari if she had seen Todd and Joani that morning. Cari said that Joani was in Chicago and that she hadn't seen Todd that morning. Jim said that that was strange because he had talked to Todd earlier and he thought that Joani was home by what Todd had said.
Ellen and Cari looked at each other. Cari boldly asked, "Was he happy?"
"Yeah, he was very happy."
Cari and Ellen both looked proud.